Comparing Magic Water Cream Gel Moisturizer with Niacinamide - 1.7 oz with 5 close alternatives
A gel-cream moisturizer formulated with niacinamide, designed for all skin types. The fragrance-free formula is intended for daily facial application.
The contenders
Start from what this moisturizer is — the closest alternatives narrow fast. We read 10,498 verified reviews across major retailers, and these are the 5 moisturizers its shoppers weigh it against.
What buyers judge on
From 10,498 reviews, 8 dimensions dominate the conversation — numbered in the order buyers raise them.
All-day hydration / lasting moisture
does it hold moisture through your whole dayCharlotte Tilbury's water cream is a sealer, not a blanket. Reviewers put it on in the morning and still feel it at the evening mirror. STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts and the Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz stretch further in either direction: one carrying dry skin through a full working day, the other clinging overnight so mornings start soft, even in deep winter. StriVectin and the Extra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz hold moisture for hours on shorter records, and L'Oréal's short record is mixed, one reviewer noting the effect stops when the jar does. STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts and the Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz hold out longest when the clock decides.
Finish on skin (dewy vs matte)
does your skin look dewy or flat by noonCharlotte Tilbury's Magic Water Cream is a watery gel that dries down to a lit-from-within sheen rather than a film, and reviewers reach for the word flawless. STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts and the Extra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz do the same work from richer bases, one leaving skin dewy and bright by mid-morning, the other luminous straight after application. The Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz shows its glow at breakfast instead. StriVectin lands softer, glowy but deliberately restrained, and L'Oréal has only a couple of reports on how skin looks. Charlotte Tilbury and STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts take first place when a lit finish leads.
Absorption speed / sinks in fast
does it disappear into skin or sit on topBase texture explains the gap here, and StriVectin's cushiony peptide cream shows it plainly: the marshmallow body gives way on contact and leaves nothing to press in. STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts goes the same way, silk gliding off within seconds. Charlotte Tilbury drinks in fast for most, though a few reviewers waited out a long dry-down, and the Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz has settled by morning. The richer Extra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz asks for a pause, and L'Oréal's heavy cream can ball up rather than sink. If dry-down time shapes the morning, StriVectin and STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts are the first names to reach for.
Hydration intensity
does your skin stay dewy or dry out by middayDry skin in a heated room separates this field. STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts collects the fullest evidence, dehydrated cheeks plumping under a cream that still feels light. Charlotte Tilbury does it with water rather than weight: skin stays soft hours later and dry patches shrink without an oily film. StriVectin plumps as deeply from a thicker cushion, the two Clarins refills, the Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz and Extra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz, drench without sitting heavy, and L'Oréal quenches flaky, mature skin on a shorter record. Deep moisture as the priority puts STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts and Charlotte Tilbury at the head of the queue.
Non-greasy texture
sinks in without the sticky feelingOil in the base decides this dimension, and Charlotte Tilbury has none: a water cream that spreads and leaves nothing tacky behind. StriVectin reaches the same place from the opposite direction, thick and cushioned yet leaving no slick, and STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts finishes clean on cheeks and T-zone alike. Both Clarins refills, the Extra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz and Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz, run rich but sink without weight or stickiness. L'Oréal is where the retinol base shows: a sizeable minority describe a cakey, heavy film that needed washing off. Skin that turns shiny by midday will be happiest with Charlotte Tilbury and StriVectin.
Anti-aging
does it actually smooth fine lines and wrinklesL'Oréal's Revitalift record breaks in two. Some reviewers watch crow's feet soften within a fortnight; others end the trial unchanged. Nothing else here reads that unevenly: StriVectin's retinol cushion carries the longest run of reports about creases above the lip filling in, and both Clarins refills, the Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz and Extra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz, are credited with a firmer jaw by month's end. STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts leans brightening, with more said about even tone than line depth, and Charlotte Tilbury's gel softens fine lines without shifting deeper wrinkles. Buyers weighing creases over glow should begin with StriVectin and the Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz.
Works under makeup
smooth base that won't pill or bunch under foundationCharlotte Tilbury's gel-cream disappears before a brush comes near it, and the field arranges itself around that. Reviewers use it ahead of primer, under tinted sunscreen, under foundation that then sits even all day. The Extra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz does the same well enough to replace a primer, and StriVectin's cushion gives makeup a smooth bed without turning oily. STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts and the Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz stay out of the way on shorter records, while L'Oréal rolls and peels under powder for most of its reviewers. If a moisturizer has to disappear under foundation, Charlotte Tilbury and the Extra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz do it without argument.
Fragrance-free / scent sensitivity
does it smell pleasant or overwhelmingWhat reviewers notice about Charlotte Tilbury here is an absence: next to no scent, nothing to clash with a scented serum. StriVectin comes closest, its faint rose read as light rather than applied. The Extra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz and STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi Watts are loved for citrus and clean soft aromas, yet both collect complaints from reviewers who found the perfume heavy all day, and the Extra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz draws that objection more often, its floral reading as overpowering to several. L'Oréal is the outlier: its fragrance follows reviewers into the night. If scent is the sticking point, Charlotte Tilbury and StriVectin are the two least likely to intrude.
The scorecard
Every claim above, counted. The full read of all products, dimension by dimension.
| All-day hydration / lasting moisture | Finish on skin (dewy vs matte) | Absorption speed / sinks in fast | Hydration intensity | Non-greasy texture | Anti-aging | Works under makeup | Fragrance-free / scent sensitivity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charlotte TilburyMagic Water Cream Gel Moisturizer with Niacinamide - 1.7 oz | 14 good · 0 bad | 17 good · 0 bad | 30 good · 4 bad | 64 good · 0 bad | 35 good · 1 bad | 12 good · 2 bad | 24 good · 0 bad | 36 good · 3 bad |
| STRIPES BEAUTY by Naomi WattsDew As I Do Ectoine + Vitamin C Brightening & Hydrating Cream | 16 good · 1 bad | 15 good · 0 bad | 31 good · 0 bad | 79 good · 0 bad | 33 good · 0 bad | 30 good · 0 bad | Too few | 36 good · 7 bad |
| ClarinsExtra-Firming Energy Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz | Too few | 15 good · 0 bad | 21 good · 3 bad | 37 good · 1 bad | 30 good · 0 bad | 31 good · 4 bad | 20 good · 1 bad | 39 good · 7 bad |
| StriVectinPeptide Plump Collagen Cushion Cream - 1.7 oz | Too few | Too few | 44 good · 0 bad | 59 good · 2 bad | 35 good · 1 bad | 65 good · 4 bad | 15 good · 0 bad | 35 good · 6 bad |
| ClarinsExtra-Firming Night Refillable Moisturizer - 1.7 oz | 16 good · 1 bad | 10 good · 0 bad | 25 good · 2 bad | 42 good · 2 bad | 28 good · 0 bad | 33 good · 2 bad | Too few | 35 good · 9 bad |
| L'OréalRevitalift Triple Power Anti-Aging Face Moisturizer | Too few | Too few | 9 good · 3 bad | 31 good · 0 bad | 16 good · 9 bad | 38 good · 15 bad | 3 good · 10 bad | 14 good · 13 bad |
Where to buy
Live prices at the retailers we track.Independent. No affiliate links, no paid placement.
Sources & references
Every read traces back to these sources. Retailer reviews are counted from official product pages (top 100 most useful per retailer) — never republished.
About Besides
Besides helps you decide what to buy by compressing real user experience along the specific dimensions that matter for each product category. Instead of choosing between marketing copy and thousands of unstructured reviews, you get a side-by-side view of how each product actually performs on the attributes you care about.